Road to Baku 2012: Jedward – “Waterline” (Ireland)

So who’s the lucky act who gets to take the pimp slot closing the first Semi-final? Oh, it’s Jedward … again! After riding a wave of momentum in the second semi-final last year, Jedward backflipped their way to an impressive 8th place last year, rehabilitating the fortunes of the once-unstoppable Irish nation at Eurovision.

Indeed Ireland hold several contest records, the most wins with 7 to their name. Three of these were consecutive victories in the 90s, another record. It’s got the highest average points total, and 34 top ten finishes out of 45 entries. Against this backdrop, the wheels really fell off the Irish machine in the 00’s, with a number of songs not qualifying, and poor results for those that did.

So Jedward appeared to be the saviours of Irish pride last year, so much so that they got to do it all again this year. The twins rose to notoriety on the UK’s 2009 X-Factor, and turned into a much talked-about novelty act, with limited vocal prowess being papered over with ridiculous staging.

Even finishing 6th in X-Factor didn’t slow them down, with a hit single and a stint on Celebrity Big Brother, so it was easy to assume that their 2010 entry was another joke for a bit more of the spotlight. There was a large degree of self-knowing in “Lipstick”, with another flashy stage-show to cover up for the vocal shortcomings. But at its core, “Lipstick” was a solid and instantly memorable pop song, with devastatingly effective visuals. So their victory seemed well deserved.

But what’s this? They seem to be taking themselves a bit more seriously with a more straightforward pop effort that feels more like an unused Westlife B-Side from 10 years ago (though it never did One Direction any harm).

The problem is that Jedward (as many novelty acts in the X-Factor did) stopped being fun as soon as they decided they weren’t going to be the joke act anymore, and everyone realised that under all that showboating were just a pair of inept pouting teenagers. I’m afraid history seems to be repeating itself if that music video is anything to go by.

Are they going for a modelling shoot? Aren’t they in on this joke and playing a role for a bit of fun and celebrity? I’m not sure anymore, and it leaves me with a rather cynical feeling in my stomach. They’ve tasted European success after “Lipstick” last year (though curiously not in the UK), is there really a market for a pair of shamelessly pouting and “Blue Steel”-ing guys if the songs aren’t up to much?

I think Ireland needs another wake-up call.

Advertisements

9 Comments

Filed under Baku 2012, Eurovision, Music, Reviews

9 responses to “Road to Baku 2012: Jedward – “Waterline” (Ireland)

  1. I saw them in Amsterdam at the Eurovision in Concert and they were brilliant. The song this year is, in my opinion, much better than Lipstick. They know how to entertain and the crowd loved them. I don’t see them as egotistical guys at all – but fun loving crowd pleasers! Good luck to Ireland this year. (I never thought I’d say that).

    • I’m glad to hear that, I haven’t seen any live performances yet, so I’ll blame the video for my unseasonably grinchy write-up!

      They really won me over in Dusseldorf, I hope they can do it again without relying so much on the spectacle. I think they might play it safe ironically by being bizarre!

  2. I don’tknow why some people think they can’t sing. I’ve owned a singing telegram company for 30 years and I’d love to have them working for me. The may only have a one octave range but their voices have a very pleasing tone and they perform with tons of personality and carisma!

    • Thanks for the comment 🙂

      They can sing to an extent, I just think they can’t compete with most of the nations on vocals. Their big strength is their personality as you say. You don’t usually get the big-voiced ballad singers doing a lot more than just sing, so there’s room for everyone!

  3. Dinlo

    I loved Lipstick. Can’t stand this.

  4. Pingback: Eurovision 2012: Semi-Final 1 preview | Verbal Diarrhoea

  5. Pingback: Eurovision 2012: Grand Final set-list & preview | Verbal Diarrhoea

  6. Pingback: Road to Copenhagen 2014: Can-Linn & Kasey Smith – “Heartbeat” (Ireland) | Verbal Diarrhoea

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s